PLAINTIFFS PREVAIL IN MOTION TO DISMISS SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND MOTION TO COMPEL ARBITRATION
DECEMBER 21, 2007
Schwartz Perry & Heller LLP is pleased to report that our firm successfully defended against a motion to dismiss, a motion for summary judgment and a motion to compel arbitration pursuant to a collective bargaining agreement, all which were made by a defendant in an action in which our clients asserted claims for gender discrimination and retaliation. The action was brought in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York. Hon. Deborah A. Batts wrote the Memorandum and Order, dated Dec. 21, 2007. It is a decision that we believe might well be of interest to our colleagues.
The Court, in denying the defendant's motion to dismiss the discrimination claim under the New York City Human Rights Law, citing Farrugia v. North Shore Univ. Hosp., 13 Misc.3d 740, 747 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Co. 2006), observed that New York State Courts have recognized that the New York City Human Rights Law was intended to be more protective than the state and federal counterparts. The court also observed, citing Jordan v. Bates Advertising, Inc., 11 Misc.3d 764, 770 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Co. 2006), that "in enacting the more protective Human Rights Law , the New York City Council has exercised a clear policy choice" which the court was bound to honor. The Court also opined, citing Jordan, that the legislative history of New York City's Administrative Code "clearly contemplates that the New York City Human Rights Law be liberally and independently construed with the aim of making it the most progressive in the nation."
The defendant also moved to compel arbitration based on a provision in one of the plaintiffs' collective bargaining agreement which stated that any claims under federal and state anti-discrimination statutes "shall be subject to the grievance and arbitration procedure...as the sole and exclusive remedy for the violations." In denying the defendant's Motion to Compel Arbitration, the court found that "there is no basis for the Court to conclude that Selmanovic personally ever waived her right to raise her New York City Human Rights Law claims in a federal forum." The court cited the Second Circuit cases of Pyette v. Pennsylvania Building Corp., 498 F.3d 88, 92 (2d Cir. 2007) and Kravar v. Triangle Services, Inc., 509 F.Supp.2d 407, 409 (S.D.N.Y. 2007), which held that a union-negotiated mandatory arbitration agreement purporting to waive a covered worker's right to a federal forum with respect to statutory rights is unenforceable.
The decision can be read by clicking here.
Our Testimonials
Our Past Clients Speak to Our Experience
-
"Always available, conscientious and extremely knowledgeable."
Outstanding lawyer. Always available, conscientious and extremely knowledgeable. Excellent at following-up both with his clients and with opposing counsel. Regardless of the size of the case, Brian will put in the work and always treat his clients with the utmost professionalism and respect.
- N.W. -
"I trusted them entirely."
I received the most compassionate and professional assistance from SP&H. I felt that Mr. Heller truly cared about me and the situation I was in. He was able to be my voice during a difficult time. He responded promptly to any correspondence, took the time to explain to me any questions or concerns, and helped ease any kind of stress that I had during a dispute with a previous employer. I highly recommend this firm. You are not just a number, they treat you like family. I trusted them entirely. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for all of your devoted time and effort in my legal matter.
- A.M. -
"Their integrity, personal attention, and knowledge are superior."
Schwartz, Perry & Heller, LLP are the most skilled Lawyers for your discrimination case in the Tri-State area. Their integrity, personal attention, and knowledge are superior. They won my case and can win yours. Nothing beats the best.- D.K. -
"Caring, smart, highly skilled negotiators"
Davida Perry and Brian Heller are very caring, attentive and highly skilled negotiators who gave me expert representation to win my negotiation and achieve my goals.- D. -
"Words are inadequate to express how truly grateful I am to Schwartz & Perry, especially Brian Heller for his help."
Words are inadequate to express how truly grateful I am to Schwartz & Perry, especially Brian Heller for his help. I first met Mr. Schwartz and Brian Heller a few years ago when I was working at an international firm in an IT role when I contacted them for the free consultation because I felt that I was being setup to be fired. I knew I was being treated unfairly by my manager. I felt utterly helpless and had no idea who to turn to. After meeting with Mr. Schwartz and Brian Heller, I came to understand that the unfair treatment I endured was actually discrimination. They counselled me through being fired and negotiating a settlement; an extremely upsetting and exhausting experience. They explained the rules of employment law while treating me with dignity and kindness. Due to the skill and knowledge of these attorneys, I received a substantial settlement and was able to move on to another company with my self-respect intact and without the financial hardship that would have resulted from losing my job. They also ensured that this employer could not damage my reputation going forward with future employers. Recently, when I had another issue with a different employer; I called Brian Heller right away. I knew that Brian, being extremely well versed on the latest employment laws, would be able to help me. Brian carefully guided me and I was able to “ride the wave” of unprofessionalism and threats of litigation coming my way from my former employer’s attorney. My former employer thought that they could bully and frighten me into staying with them longer so that my new job opportunity would no longer be available, and then they could let me go when it was convenient for them - and I’d be out of work. They didn’t know that I have a Secret Weapon – Brian Heller! Once Brian was on the case, those threats ceased and I was able to accept my new wonderful job and leave the worry and stress behind. I highly recommend Brian Heller and Schwartz & Perry as a firm. Over the years Brian has always treated me with kindness and respect and I have peace of mind because I have someone I trust who is on my side, who can guide me and who is willing and extremely capable of protecting my rights.- Former Client -
"From day 1 of the consultation to the very end I felt like the most important client to the firm."
Amazing team of Attorneys. From day 1 of the consultation to the very end I felt like the most important client to the firm. Brian Heller who I dealt with personally was amazing. Whether it was a call or email responses were very prompt and I was kept informed every step of the way. Even a few calls just to check in and say hello. Truly an incredible experience and I would recommend them to anyone seeking justice. If they take your case they will fight with you to the end. A+- D.W. -
"We remain tremendously grateful for his support and look forward to working with him again."
On short notice, Brian Heller reviewed contracts with complex international dimensions and found important discrepancies that I and other senior-level executives had missed completely. He was fast, thorough, and detail-oriented in providing pragmatic advice that enabled us to be sure that we were getting the fairest and best possible treatment under the law. We remain tremendously grateful for his support and look forward to working with him again.- Eric -
"Davida Perry not only did an amazing job calming down my nerves but she fought for me tooth and nail and did a great job securing what my past employer owed me."
After having a terrible experience at my last job, facing the anxiety again of having to rehash the treatment was daunting. Davida Perry not only did an amazing job calming down my nerves but she fought for me tooth and nail and did a great job securing what my past employer owed me. I won’t lie, there were moments I wanted to give up, but Davida was always there to help me stay focused and realize that I didn’t need to let them win. She was really great at countering all of their arguments, I pity anyone that would try to prove her wrong. She thought of everything we need and kept me constantly updated. Mostly what I appreciated about Davida was her kindness, and her genuine care for my mental health. She wanted to make sure I was taking care of myself during a very trying time. I cannot recommend this firm enough. They all clearly care about their clients and want to do best for you. Don’t be afraid to stand up for yourself, and if you’re worried about the challenges that lie ahead be sure to team with Schwartz Perry & Heller, they will have your back and fight for justice.- T.B.